Weight Loss Quakery

 

From ancient potions to modern miracle pills, weight-loss quackery has thrived for centuries, preying on people’s (particularly women) insecurities and desire for quick fixes. Despite medical advancements and a better understanding of human physiology, the promise of effortless weight loss continues to lure millions into the arms of charlatans. 

Ancient Roots: The First Fads

Weight-loss quackery is not a modern invention. In ancient Greece and Rome, elite men and women were already fixated on body size and appearance. Hippocrates, the "father of medicine," recommended vomiting and excessive exercise for the overweight. Roman doctors sometimes prescribed purgatives, hot baths, and long walks in thick clothing to induce sweating and fat loss.

Meanwhile, dubious “remedies” were already circulating. Herbal concoctions claimed to suppress appetite or speed up digestion, often with little to no scientific basis—practices that have echoed through time.

By the 1700s, weight loss had become a profitable niche in the booming market of patent medicine. Entrepreneurs sold “reducing tonics,” “purifying elixirs,” and “fat-dissolving powders,” claiming miraculous results. These products were unregulated, often made with alcohol, opium, or dangerous stimulants.

In the 1800s, the Victorian obsession with refinement and slenderness birthed a flood of bizarre treatments. One popular figure, William Banting, published a pamphlet in 1863 advocating a low-carb diet—a rare example of actual effectiveness—but his name was quickly co-opted by unscrupulous marketers. "Banting cures" of dubious composition popped up all over Europe and America.

Steam baths, vibrating belts, and body-wrapping devices also gained traction during this era. They promised to "sweat off" fat, even though they mostly caused dehydration and temporary weight loss at best.

Early 20th Century: Dangerous Pills and Fad Diets

The early 1900s saw the rise of pharmaceutical solutions to weight loss—some shockingly unsafe. One notorious product was Dinitrophenol (DNP), introduced in the 1930s. It worked by increasing metabolism to dangerous levels, often causing fever, cataracts, and even death. It was banned by the FDA in 1938, but black-market use persists even today.

Around the same time, cigarette companies began marketing smoking as a weight-control tool. Lucky Strike’s infamous ad campaign, “Reach for a Lucky instead of a sweet,” cynically encouraged women to replace food with tobacco.

The 1950s to 1970s brought more appetite suppressants and amphetamine-based drugs. While some did reduce weight, they came with addiction, heart risks, and severe mood disorders.

Late 20th Century: Celebrity Endorsements and TV Scams

Television and celebrity culture supercharged the diet industry in the late 20th century. From Richard Simmons’ aerobics tapes to the grapefruit diet and the cabbage soup craze, fad diets reached millions of homes.

Meanwhile, infomercials promoted vibrating platforms, “fat-burning” creams, and magnetic belts, all claiming effortless results. One infamous example, the AbTronic, promised six-pack abs through passive electrical stimulation. Its makers were fined millions for false advertising.

Diet pills made a comeback, too. The fen-phen craze of the 1990s ended in tragedy after the combination drug was linked to heart valve damage and pulmonary hypertension, leading to its removal from the market.

The 21st Century: Detoxes, Teatoxes, and TikTok Gimmicks

Modern weight-loss quackery is a slick, high-tech operation. Influencers push “teatoxes” (laxative teas), waist trainers, and apple cider vinegar gummies with the sheen of health and wellness branding. These products often have no clinical backing and rely on manipulated before-and-after photos and fake testimonials.

“Clean eating” and “detox” culture have normalized extreme restriction under the guise of health. Juice cleanses, colonics, and restrictive elimination diets often lack scientific support and may even harm metabolism or gut health.

Social media has accelerated the spread of these trends, especially among young users. TikTok and Instagram are flooded with tips that range from useless to dangerous, often promoted by people with no medical training.

Why Weight-Loss Quackery Endures

Despite decades of education and regulatory crackdowns, the weight-loss industry remains rife with fraud. Why?

Desperation: Weight loss is a deeply emotional issue. People often seek fast results, especially when facing societal pressure or health risks.

Marketing Power: Quacks are master marketers. They know how to frame their products as “natural,” “ancient,” or “doctor-approved.”

Slow Science: Real, sustainable weight loss through diet, exercise, and behavior change is slow. Quacks exploit the gap between desire and reality.

Regulatory Gaps: Supplements and diet products are lightly regulated in many countries. That makes it easy to sell ineffective or harmful products with minimal consequences.

A Better Way Forward

The fight against weight-loss quackery is ongoing. Education, consumer skepticism, and evidence-based approaches to health are key. While there’s no quick fix, medical science does offer real tools—nutritional guidance, physical activity, behavioral therapy, and in some cases, medications or surgery—for those who need them.

Ultimately, the lesson of history is clear: if it sounds too good to be true, it is.

_____________________

I myself have tried many of these diets, from bread and water, to high protein-based diets, to fasting. I am currently taking Trulicity, which seems to be the new wonder drug, with some favorable results.